Criminal law notes

Why the first 48 hours matter in a criminal case

The first two days of a criminal matter often set its direction. Statements are given, documents are signed and the first court order is passed. This note is general information and not legal advice. It describes what the law provides at that stage and why those provisions matter.

Notice before arrest

Not every case begins with an arrest. Section 35 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) allows the police, in cases where arrest is not required, to issue a notice asking a person to appear. This replaced the notice under Section 41A of the Code of Criminal Procedure. For offences punishable with imprisonment up to seven years, a notice is the expected first step, and arrest is meant to be the exception, with reasons recorded by the officer if arrest follows.

A person who complies with the notice is, in general, not to be arrested unless the officer records reasons. The notice should identify the case, the police station and the date and time to attend. Read it carefully, keep a copy, and note how it was served. A message on a phone app alone may not amount to proper service, and the Supreme Court has said so in the context of notices of this kind.

If there is an arrest

Several protections attach to arrest, many of them rooted in Article 22 of the Constitution:

  • Grounds of arrest. The person must be told why they are being arrested.
  • A lawyer of choice. Article 22(1) gives the right to consult and be defended by an advocate. Section 38 of the BNSS also allows the arrested person to meet an advocate of their choice during interrogation, though not throughout it.
  • Information to a relative or friend. The law requires the police to inform a person nominated by the arrested person.
  • Production before a Magistrate. Article 22(2) requires production before the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours of arrest, excluding the time needed to travel. Section 58 of the BNSS carries forward the same 24-hour rule.

Why production before a Magistrate matters

The Magistrate is the first judicial check on the arrest. The Magistrate looks at whether the arrest and the production followed the law and decides whether the accused should be remanded to police or judicial custody, or released. It is at this stage that the arrested person, or an advocate, can tell the Magistrate of any concern, such as ill-treatment or an irregularity in the arrest. Remand rules are in Section 187 of the BNSS, which also governs how long police custody can be sought.

Early bail

In a bailable offence, bail is a matter of right. In a non-bailable offence it is a matter of the court's discretion, based on the nature of the allegation, the material, the likelihood of absconding or tampering with evidence, and similar factors. A bail application can be moved at the first production, and if refused, before the Sessions Court and then the High Court. If a person fears arrest before it happens, anticipatory bail under Section 482 of the BNSS is available in appropriate cases.

Statements and signatures

The early days are when most statements are recorded. A few cautions are commonly given:

  1. Read before you sign. Do not sign a document you have not read or do not understand.
  2. Keep copies of every notice, memo and receipt.
  3. Be accurate. An inaccurate statement can be used to question credibility later.
  4. Know the setting. Statements made in some special-law cases are treated differently under the relevant statute.

Records that help later

Write down, as soon as possible, the time of detention or arrest, the names of the officers, where you were kept, when you were produced and what documents were given. A timeline made while memory is fresh is useful to anyone who later reviews the case.

Family members

Relatives often need to act quickly in the early hours. They can note the police station, the case number if available, the name of the investigating officer and the court where the person will be produced. They should not attempt to settle the matter with the complainant or the police without understanding the legal consequences.

For a broader view, see the page on criminal law and bail and the note on matters before the High Court of Karnataka.

Frequently asked questions

Does the police have to arrest after registering an FIR?

No. For many offences the police can issue a notice of appearance under Section 35 of the BNSS instead, and arrest is to be used with recorded reasons.

Within what time must an arrested person be produced before a Magistrate?

Within 24 hours of arrest, excluding the journey time, under Article 22(2) of the Constitution and Section 58 of the BNSS.

Can I meet a lawyer during interrogation?

Section 38 of the BNSS allows the arrested person to meet an advocate of their choice during interrogation, though not throughout.

Is bail available at the first hearing?

It can be applied for at the first production. Whether it is granted depends on the offence and the facts.

This article is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and the law and its interpretation change. Please consult an advocate about your specific facts before acting.

Keep reading

Call WhatsApp